
We have Strongsville news! The Strongsville Sports Collectors Convention (an annual vintage-focused cards and memorabilia show) has a new location. After moving around over the last few years, the convention will now be in Columbus, Ohio, in the Ohio Expo Center.
The location is twice as big as the one from this past April’s show. And according to David Chase’s Instagram Reel (he’s a great follow, by the way), that means they’ll take on more dealers, including those from the wait list and new dealers, so if you’re interested in setting up there, fill this out.
Next year’s show will be Friday, April 16, to Sunday, April 18, and it’s about 6.5 miles from the John Glenn Columbia International Airport and near multiple hotels. I went this past year for the first time and it was great, so I’ll need to figure out if I can go in 2027. You can read more info about the updates here.
In this issue you'll find:
Auction highlights
News in the hobby
The continuing influence of seasonality on vintage football player indexes
Art Shell’s rookie card and player profile
ICYMI
Recent Vintage Card Voyage videos
Let’s get into it.
Ever wonder how they afford that? Check the receipts.
Admit it. You’ve wondered, how much money do they make?
Money is our last true taboo. We talk about therapy and bad dates, but guard our bank statements like classified files.
The podcast What We Spend blows the safe wide open.
In every episode, real people share their actual, unedited transaction histories. You'll hear about the secret credit card debt, the reckless impulse buys, and the hidden sacrifices nobody talks about at brunch.
It’s revealing, intimate, and strangely validating to finally hear the truth behind other people’s bank accounts.
Auction Highlights
In order of closing date:
Clean Sweep Auctions (ending on November 18)
Sirius Sports Cards Auction (ending on November 19)
Heritage Auction Sports Showcase (ending on November 21)
Detroit City Sports Premium Auction (ending on November 21)
Iconic Auctions November 2026 Feature Auction of Autographs, Trading Cards & Memorabilia (ending on November 21)
Other active auctions:
Classic Auctions Historical Hockey and Sports Memorabilia Auction (ends on November 24 - primarily hockey, but there are other sports as well)
Hunt Auctions Internet Auction (ends on December 2)
Leland’s 2026 Fall Classic (ends on December 5)
2026 Fall Goldin 100 (ends on December 6 - all bids start at $1,000)
Wheatland Vintage and Current Era Sports Card & Memorabilia Auction (ends on December 13)
*These listings are for informational purposes only. Please do your own research regarding these auctions before bidding.
News Briefs
Hobby Thoughts: Seasonality and Older Vintage Football Cards
After looking at Hall of Fame football players with rookie cards in the 1970s last week, I decided to look at ones with rookie cards in the 1950s and ‘60s, with the assumption that there likely wouldn’t be as much movement as there were for players in the 1970s, with current buyers not necessarily having as much connection with these players.
I used the same 365-day range: the offseason (Feb. 8, 2025 - Sept. 4, 2025) and the 2025 NFL season (Sept. 4, 2025 - Feb. 8, 2026) for the player indexes that existed. Lending credence to my assumption, of the 113 players with rookie cards during the ‘50s and ‘60s, only 13 of them even had an index, with indexes generally determined based on enough sales to justify having them.
Player Index | 2/8/25-9/4/25 Pct. Change | 9/4/25-2/8/26 Pct. Change |
Larry Csonka | -3.88 | 39.86 |
LeRoy Kelly | -12.54 | 41.06 |
Bob Griese | -35.68 | 210.2 |
Gale Sayers | -1.64 | 1.13 |
Fred Biletnikoff | 1.06 | 2.6 |
Dick Butkus | -1.69 | 38.04 |
Fran Tarkenton | 1.74 | 4.61 |
Joe Namath | -9.55 | 11.28 |
Johnny Unitas | 18.42 | -10.75 |
Otto Graham | 17.07 | 9.06 |
Bart Starr | 64.33 | 1.63 |
Jim Brown | -2.37 | 10.28 |
Methodology:
The players chosen were all Hall of Famers, had rookie cards between 1950 and 1969, and had Card Ladder player indexes
Each player index was given both date ranges to determine the percentage change in the value of the index
Not all Hall of Fame players have player indexes, as each index has cards Card Ladder determines eligible based on sales activity (more info here), and there is a range of the number of cards on indexes
One of the 13 players (Carl Eller) didn’t have any sales data, so he wasn’t in the above list. The offseason period did seem to produce less positive movement, with seven of the 12 player indexes moving down, compared to only one doing so during the NFL season. And, not surprisingly, thee median (middle) percentage movement for the offseason was -1.67%, compared to 9.67% during the NFL season.
As noted last week, during the the season itself, the (admittedly modern-heavy) Football index was up 14.7% and the Vintage index was up 12.64%, while during the offseason, the Football index was up 5.23% and the Vintage index was up 7.89%. The Football index demonstrated a seasonality influence, while the median from the above player indexes lagged behind both the Football and Vintage indexes.
Four players managed to finish both periods with positive movement, while, in a nice surprise, none of the indexes moved down both periods of time. I can’t explain the Bob Griese movement during the NFL season, and it’s especially notable because of the five cards in his index, none are his rookie card (they’re all 1978-1981 Topps cards).
These results continue to support the idea that vintage cards tend to move more positively during the NFL season as compared to the offseason. Next, I’ll take a look at vintage basketball.
Vintage HOF Rookie Card: Art Shell
Following a Hall of Fame playing career, Shell coached for nearly 20 years, including becoming the first Black head coach in modern NFL history in 1989, and the second ever, with the first being Fritz Pollard in 1925.
Art Shell - T
HOF Induction in 1989
8-time Pro Bowler including seven consecutive
4-time All-Pro (two first-team and two second-team selections)
2-time Super Bowl champ
HOF All-1970s Team
Career AV (Approximate Value) - 122

1973 Topps #77
Grade | PSA Pop Count | SGC Pop Count | BVG Pop Count |
|---|---|---|---|
10 | 6 | 0 | 0 |
9 | 100 | 7 | 3 |
8 | 331 | 14 | 13 |
7 | 206 | 20 | 12 |

Taking a noticeable drop in the last half of the sales, the average price came out to be $61.10.
ICYMI
Vintage Card Voyage: Recent Videos
This is the YouTube channel I co-host with my friend Ken.

Subscribe for future issues, share with those you think would enjoy the newsletter, and please also check out and subscribe to Vintage Card Voyage.
Thanks for reading.
Marc

