This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsored by

I had a packed weekend, so this issue is on the shorter side.

I did have the good fortune of locating a small lot of 1958 Topps football cards on Maxsold (if you haven’t heard of it, it’s an auction site where a lot of estate sales that presumably don’t want people coming through their homes list their items they want to sell).

Amazingly, I won the auction (one that happened to end while we taped one of our Vintage Card Voyage episodes), and it included a few Hall of Famers.

Y.A. Tittle

Raymond Berry

As you can see, the condition, uh, varied. Of the 40 cards in the lot, we needed 15 for the set, so we now only need 52 cards, which are listed here:

2 Bobby Layne

34 Sam Baker

58 Ron Kramer

95 Billy Wilson

4 Bill Barnes

36 Vic Zucco

60 Gern Nagler

96 Packers Team

7 Howard Cassady

37 Geroge Tarasovic

62 Jim Brown

103 Jim Ringo

8 James Dooley

39 Dick Stanfel

63 Joe Marconi

104 Joe Krupa

9 Browns Team

40 Jerry Norton

64 R.C. Owens

106 Art Donovan

11 Pete Brewster

41 49ers Team

67 Tom Wilson

108 Ken Kellar

12 Alan Ameche

44 Ted Marchibroda

69 Cardinals Team

109 Eagles Team

16 Gino Marchetti

47 John Carson

73 Frank Gifford

111 Dick Bielski

23 Zeke Bratkowski

49 Billy Wells

78 Ray Mathews

114 Willie Galimore

26 Ken Konz

52 Lou Groza

83 Don Heinrich

124 Dick Moegle

28 C. Brettschneider

53 Rick Casares

85 Rams Team

128 P. Carpenter

31 Al Carmichael

56 Gary Knafelc

90 Sonny Jurgensen

129 George Blanda

32 Bobby Dillon

57 Earl Morrall

94 Tobin Rote

132 Don Bosseler

As a reminder, we hope to complete the set and then have it auctioned off, with the proceeds going to a charity that Ken and I will determine, but it will likely be a local charity that helps children with cancer and/or their families in a meaningful way.

If you happen to have one of these cards and would like to help us complete the set, or if you’d like to donate some money toward one of the bigger cards (read: the Jim Brown rookie), please email us at [email protected]. Any help you can provide would be greatly appreciated.

And don’t forget to take advantage of my referral program near the bottom of the email.

In this issue you'll find:

  • Auction highlights

  • News in the hobby

  • Ray Guy’s rookie card and player profile

  • ICYMI

  • Recent Vintage Card Voyage videos

Let’s get into it.

I Almost Threw Out My Keurig. It Wasn't Broken.

Every cup from my Keurig started tasting weak, flat, stale — so I unplugged it and stuck it in a closet. Then I learned the dirty secret of grocery store K-Cups: by the time a pod reaches your kitchen, it's usually spent months going from factory to warehouse to truck to shelf. The flavor oils are long gone. Some brands even over-roast to hide it.

The fix wasn't a new machine. It was fresh pods from Angelino's, a family-owned L.A. roastery that roasts, packs, and ships within 3–5 days — straight to your door, from 39¢ a cup. Over 1,000,000 happy customers. 50+ flavors, no subscription required, and 15% off your first order, applied automatically at checkout.

Auction Highlights

In order of closing date:

Sirius Sports Cards Auction (ending October 8)

Collector Investor Auctions (ending on October 11)

Other active auctions:

Clean Sweep Champions Auction (ends on October 14)

Prestige Collectibles (Japanese baseball cards and memorabilia - ends on October 17)

Goldin 2026 Monthly Sports Elite #9 (starts at $100 - ends on October 17)

Heritage Fall Sports Catalog Auction (ends on October 23-25 - see news article below)

Vintage HOF Rookie Card: Ray Guy

The former punter who spent his entire playing career with the Raiders organization, Guy has the distinction of being the only full-time punter in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Ray Guy - P

HOF Induction in 2014

  • 7-time Pro Bowler, including six consecutive

  • 4-time All-Pro (three first-team selections and one second-team selection)

  • 3-time punting yard average leader

  • Member of the HOF All-1970s Team

  • Career AV (Approximate Value) - 44

1974 Topps #219

Grade

PSA Pop Count

SGC Pop Count

BVG Pop Count

10

3

0

TBD

9

54

2

TBD

8

191

11

TBD

7

189

22

TBD

The average price came out to be $88.51.

ICYMI

Vintage Card Voyage: Recent Videos

This is the YouTube channel I co-host with my friend Ken.

Subscribe for future issues, share with those you think would enjoy the newsletter, and please also check out and subscribe to Vintage Card Voyage.

Thanks for reading.

Marc

Thoughts on today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate

Reply

Avatar

or to participate